Antonio's Real New York Pizza
closed today
Pizza place Italian restaurant
Just outside of Rocky Mountain National Park you will find Real New York Pizza made by New Yorkers! It all started in 1892 with the birth of my Great Grandfather Francesco Scerbo. At age 15, he was put on a boat which arrived at Ellis Island some 6 months later causing his pants to be too short.. By the 1920's, he had moved to the Bronx then eventually settled in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn buying a brownstone that my great Aunt resides in to this day- in her 90's!
Growing up in New York with access to the authentic Italian food of Brooklyn and Long Island, I did not realize how lucky we were to have access to so much great food until moving to Colorado. Read more
Reviews
Updates (5)
Review Antonio's Real New York Pizza
Loading comments-box...
Benjamin M. 2016-03-20Love this place, hands down best pizza I've had in northern Colorado. Little Italy sandwich is the best menu item but a close second is the Francesco...
Sarah P. 2016-01-24Pizza was totally unexpected and delicious, staff was friendly and fast. Will be back everytime we visit Estes Park and will be sure to spread the...
Crystal C. 2016-01-04Amazing food and all around awesome guys!! Highly recommend you stop in if your anywhere near Estes Park. I'll be here patiently awaiting one to open...
Talia F. 2017-05-19As always a great experience!! They have amazing food and the staff are always happy and treat us like family!
James O. 2017-05-13Great NY pizza and garlic knots,whenever i get back to Colorado i will be here for pizza
Holli A. 2017-05-05Truly the best pizza I have ever had. The warm, friendly staff makes you feel like you just stopped into your cousin's place for a slice. This is...
Maria M. 2017-05-03Such an awesome place and atmosphere! The giant pizza they make is amazing. So many different toppings and cheeses.
David G. 2017-05-01Great Pizza! A must if you go to Estes Park or you're just on he hunt for good pizza!
Rick S. 2017-04-28Awesome people. Awesome pizza. I recommend the calzone with pepperoni and roasted red bell pepper. Big enough to feed two hungry people, or eat it...
Rory P. 2017-04-22My second time... I'll keep going back. Delicious!
Phil Cosper J. 2017-04-12Love this place!! Wish we could pick it up and move it to KC.
Adrianna D. 2017-03-26Yummy pizza, yummy garlic knots, amazing service. Everything about this place I loved. Definitely going here every time I visit Estes!
Star Elizabeth C. 2017-03-20We loved the food, atmosphere and most of all the people! Antonio was very friendly, checked on us periodically and has a great appreciation for great...
Preston B. 2017-03-11Visiting Estes Park and went here on a whim. Excellent pizza....friendly staff!
Joe J. 2017-03-05Friendly and awesome environment. Staff was exceptional!
Chris C. 2017-03-05Wonderful family atmosphere and great food! Enjoyable lunch after a morning hike.
Brian D. 2017-03-04The meatball and onion pizza is excellent. Cool people, great service and excellent pizza. If you are in Estes and want good pizza. This is the place!
Johnny R. 2017-03-02I am a New Yorker, and this is excellent New York Style Pizza.
Dana Williams B. 2017-02-27The pizza was absolutely delicious!!! The staff was very friendly and courteous. We observed the owner as he stopped at each table (including ours) to...
Mary B. 2017-02-20This was excellent!! Please don't miss it. And we saw five large bull elk outside afterwards. Awesome.
Updates from Antonio's Real New York Pizza
Antonio's Real New York P. 2018-01-22
YOU CAN'T MAKE THIS S**T UP: on Saturday, a guy comes in who is from Brooklyn with his friend from CO. We start talking and I say "My family's factory was on Plymouth under the Manhattan bridge. He says "I know exactly where that is. My buddy has a furnit
YOU CAN'T MAKE THIS S**T UP: on Saturday, a guy comes in who is from Brooklyn with his friend from CO. We start talking and I say "My family's factory was on Plymouth under the Manhattan bridge. He says "I know exactly where that is. My buddy has a furnit
Antonio's Real New York P. 2018-01-21
These are proofing for tomorrow. They will be ready at 3pm.
These are proofing for tomorrow. They will be ready at 3pm.
Antonio's Real New York P. 2018-01-21
My grandma Ann was one of best women to ever step foot on planet earth. My last meal with her was a Grandma pie from Gino’s on Elmont Rd. In NY. The Grandma pie will be named for her at our store to commemorate 97 years of caring for her family. . . . #g
My grandma Ann was one of best women to ever step foot on planet earth. My last meal with her was a Grandma pie from Gino’s on Elmont Rd. In NY. The Grandma pie will be named for her at our store to commemorate 97 years of caring for her family. . . . #g
Antonio's Real New York P. 2018-01-20
Bagels at Noon today!!! Last batch sold out in the first 20 minutes we were open, yesterday. Baking now.
Bagels at Noon today!!! Last batch sold out in the first 20 minutes we were open, yesterday. Baking now.
Antonio's Real New York P. 2018-01-19
Bagels at 3pm today. 2 dozen already sold. Who wants some? Call the store 970-586-7275. More tomorrow. I’m making the dough now. Update 4pm, all sold out. More at noon Saturday!
Bagels at 3pm today. 2 dozen already sold. Who wants some? Call the store 970-586-7275. More tomorrow. I’m making the dough now. Update 4pm, all sold out. More at noon Saturday!
Popularity of Antonio's Real New York Pizza
Social Media Popularity Score: This value is based on the number of visitors, checkins, and likes on Facebook in the last few months.
Most activity in December:
Antonio's Real New York Pizza has a total of 5575 visitors (checkins) and 7986 likes.
20 reviews of Antonio's Real New York Pizza.
Average grade
5
av 5.
Totally 80s Pizza & Museum
Oskar Blues Grill & Brew Lyons